> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.thisdayinmetal.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Can’t Ask for Better than We’ve Gotten, But We Should Surely Ask for More: Down’s Volume V
- URL: https://www.thisdayinmetal.com/cant-ask-for-better-than-weve-gotten-but-we-should-surely-ask-for-more-downs-volume-v/
- Published: 2026-11-19T00:01:12.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-19T00:02:26.000Z
- Author: Ed Hackimer
- Tags: Album Reviews, #albumreviews, Down, Phil Anselmo, Pepper Keenan, Kirk Windstein, Pat Bruders, Jimmy Bower

There are very few bands, if any these days, that can draw the heavy metal world’s collective attention and anticipation when they announce a new record quite like **Down** can – and there’s good reason for that. For starters, you never really know when you’re going to get one. That’s been evident since the seven-year gap between their earth-shattering debut *NOLA* in 1995 and *A Bustle in Your Hedgerow* finally being released in 2002, which felt like an eternity to my young ears. Considering now that it’s been twelve years since the second installment of *Down IV,* the longest span without a new album in the band’s existence, and the hype for *Volume V*, out this Friday through **Nuclear Blast Records**, we are on the precipice of maybe the most anticipated release of the band’s career. 

That’s not to say that there’s any pressure for the band members themselves. Their storied status in the metal world is built upon the aforementioned *NOLA*, a watershed recording drenched in southern and sludgy lore, plus the subsequent discography they’ve built whenever it’s possible for them to reconvene at **Nodferatu’s Lair.** The legend of **Down** precedes the band itself, starting before anyone even knew who was in the group based on a three-song demo, a few t-shirts emblazoned with **Pepper Keenan** wearing **Chris Cornell’s** crown from the “Jesus Christ Pose” video, and the mythic phrase: “The Brotherhood of Eternal Sleep.” As the years have worn on since those early demo days at the turn of the 1990s, every member of the band has risen to a new level of success with their respective groups: **Phil Anselmo’s** emotional journey navigating the meteoric rise, fall, and tragedy within **Pantera** before the recent celebration shows; **Kirk Windstein** and **Pat Bruders** embracing the newfound appreciation for **Crowbar**; **Pepper** joining and leaving and then returning again to **Corrosion of Conformity**;   **Jimmy Bower** being the driving force behind **Eyehategod** and filling in for a few of the bands mentioned above on drums. But before they were anybody, they were building the legend of **Down** out of a garage jam that continues to the present day any time they’re in a room together. It’s that spirit that embodies every release: searching for the ultimate riff and the definitive groove within that room are paramount to any **Down** record, and *Volume V* is no exception to this rule.

![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/db/e2/dbe2ac7e-62ef-4b13-917a-63221a045127/content/images/2026/11/DOWN-by-Danin-Drahos-IMG-1261.png)

Kirk, Pepper, Phil, Pat, and Jimmy (photo credit: Danin Drahos).

The majority of *Volume V* was written across two sessions, with some songs coming together as they jammed face-to-face, in a tradition that dates back to *A Bustle in Your Hedgerow*, which was famously written in roughly 4 weeks time. **Pepper** and **Kirk** decided to record their guitars simultaneously, adding another layer of rawness to a group that already lacks the traditional polish that’s become commonplace in today’s recording, and the results are marvelous. *Volume V* is a record that sees Down building on its timeless foundation, somehow sounding heavier than before while exploring new territory as a band. With four songs clocking in at over seven minutes, and a total runtime of over 57 minutes across 10 tracks, some might be inclined to call *Volume V* slightly on the progressive side, but it seems to be more likely a byproduct of the boys in Down driving the riffs and letting them flow to their satisfaction. 

The album opens with a menacing riff to kick off “The Myth” that firmly reminds you of which band’s name is written on this album cover. It quickly shifts into a fast but heavy-as-hell **Trouble**\-esque lick that paces a fair amount of the first track. Phil’s repeat refrain of “when times are tough, they call on us, they count on us, they call to us” serves a double meaning to any listener, like myself, awaiting this record and is a perfect reintroduction as an album opener. Likewise, his introduction to the mid-song interlude (“Smoke it!”) invokes the similar transition and change of pace in **Black Sabbath’s** “Killing Yourself to Live,” reminding you that **Down** remain cognizant of their heroes and forefathers. A clever **Pat Bruders** bassline opens the second track, “Merciful Fate,” and that melody repeats throughout the seven minutes of this highly anticipated collaboration. **Phil’s** lyrics reflect upon the recklessness of his youth and the looming threat of death, giving way to the title that triggered the idea to get **King Diamond** on backing vocals. You could have given me a hundred guesses about who would be the first guest vocalist on a **Down** song, especially given there’s two other lead singers in the band, and I would have never guessed the metal icon from **Mercyful Fate.**  Saying it out even sounds like it should not compute musically, but the **King** and **Phil** complement each other incredibly well and make this one of the must-listen songs of the year. 

“Turn Out the Light” picks the pace back up after a slight slowdown, delivering a throwback riff that wouldn’t feel out of place on *Over the Under*, before shifting to a heavier, grinding section for **Phil** to repeat the chorus. It’s a straight-ahead ripper without any meandering, and at just over four minutes, it’s the shortest and maybe most traditional song on the album. The next cut starts with an introduction seasoned listeners should find familiar. **Anselmo’s** opening line “This is one called ‘The Message’” following a little dance on the hi-hats from **Jimmy Bower** conjures the beginning of “Losing All,” but rather than launch into high-speed dual guitars, this one starts off with a little groovier before kicking in full. **Phil** offers words of motivation to those struggling throughout, his message to those having difficulty taking back their lives from whatever demons they may have. The sprawling “Causeway Grief,” a forlorn ode to driving over the bridge that crosses **Lake Pontchartrain** and one of many local NOLA references on *Volume V*, starts with slow-moving introduction that echoes “Beneath the Tides” and trudges forward, the musical equivalent of this slow drive. The track explodes on its second half and **Phil** bellows, “Drive slow, ride epically…roll some smoke and burn and roll on….” over wailing guitar leads from **Keenan** and **Windstein,** creating one of the high points (no pun) of the album. 

![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/db/e2/dbe2ac7e-62ef-4b13-917a-63221a045127/content/images/2026/11/IMG_5242-3.jpg)

The lead single from the album, “Blood Oath,” returns us to bludgeoning, hypnotic riff territory, trampling along underneath Phil’s most guttural vocals on the record. **Anselmo’s** cryptic lyrics anoint a figure as “the soul keeper of a blood oath,” announcing that “we’re on a death march in exile,” while sprinkling in reference to the Quarter, Metairie, Lakeview, and Chalmette – familiar areas for New Orleans locals. From there, **Down’s** approach gets a little less traditional that what we’ve come to expect from them, but with great results. “They Walk the Night” tells the tale of a failed exorcism, bookended by the traditional riffing you’d expect split up by a meandering, somewhat subdued middle section of the song with an ad-lib vibe. Starting with a softer introduction before giving way to jagged guitars, “They Came From Dust” is the least traditional **Down** song on *Volume V* in terms of sound and Phil’s creative vocal delivery on the chorus, but it is for sure a fun ride. 

While we’ve encountered more melodic and more reserved sections throughout the record to this point, “Ozz” sees the band stripping it all the way down in the vein of “Jail” and “Where I’m Going.” Clean, bright acoustic guitar and hand-drums lay the foundation for a requiem for the **Prince of Darkness**, a tribute to the metal icon whose presence was felt during the writing and recording of *Volume V* according to Anselmo. 

Considering any of the band’s previous full-length efforts, there’s a certain sense of expectation when it comes to the final track. Whether it’s the monolithic “Bury Me in Smoke,” the haunting “Landing on the Mountains of Megiddo,” or the majestic “Nothing in Return (Walk Away),” **Down** have traditionally ended their records with an anthemic exclamation point. These songs, whether by design or incidental, are also generally over seven minutes long. “Twice Told Tales” satisfies all of these criteria exceedingly well, with a crushing, upbeat riff, accentuated by the dual guitar leads that weave in and out of *Volume V* at the perfect times. As **Phil** wails the chorus for the last time, it shifts to a simple acoustic passage that draws us to the final relent ofthis powerhouse album*.*

![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/db/e2/dbe2ac7e-62ef-4b13-917a-63221a045127/content/images/2026/11/IMG_5115-2.jpg)

Down live at Jones Beach Theater in August 2026 (photo credit: me).

When the dust finally settles, what we’re left with is another testament to the incredible magic that’s created when **Phil Anselmo, Pepper Keenan, Kirk Windstein, Pat Bruders,** and **Jimmy Bower** step in to a jam room. With the age and wisdom of thirty-five years worth of collective songwriting experience, **Down** have taken the unshakeable foundation they built so many years ago and transformed it into its heaviest and rawest form, while paying homage to their forebears and still pushing the boundaries of their own unique, inimitable sound. *Volume V* is another monumental achievement that only adds to the mystique of one of the most reliable, celebrated, and indispensable metal bands around, adding to their sludgy, southern lore. Fans like myself who have waited over a decade for new **Down** material will not be disappointed – the power of the riff (still) compels me! My advice to you is to cherish this record and play it loud, because if history is any indicator, it might be a long time before the next one arrives. If not, as **Phil** puts it to close out the final minutes of *Volume V,* “you’re going to be one sorry bastard.”

---

![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/db/e2/dbe2ac7e-62ef-4b13-917a-63221a045127/content/images/2026/11/images-3.jpg)

**Overall Score:** 8.5/10 Smoking Jesus shirts

**Standout Tracks:** “The Myth,” “Merciful Fate,” “Turn Out the Light,” “Causeway Grief,” “Blood Oath,” “Twice Told Tales”

**Recommendation:** Embrace this album, play it at maximum volume, and if you’re so inclined, follow the advice from “Causeway Grief”….roll some smoke and burn and roll on! 

---

**Down's** *Volume V* will be released worldwide on Friday, November 20th through **Nuclear Blast Records**. You can check out a number of pre-order options at the website linked below.

[Volume VDown![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/db/e2/dbe2ac7e-62ef-4b13-917a-63221a045127/content/images/icon/favicon_2-50373255-91a6-4442-a953-d771ce125a01.jpg)Down![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/db/e2/dbe2ac7e-62ef-4b13-917a-63221a045127/content/images/thumbnail/logo_82698e3a-3d1b-4614-9bb2-53a140c9c0f1-e4af7bc9-cabc-465c-a80b-1c1ba319a21a.png)](https://down-nola.com/collections/volume-v?ref=thisdayinmetal.com)

---

**The Great NOLA Trendkill**, featuring **Black Label Society, Pantera, Corrosion of Conformity, Crowbar, Eyehategod, Down,** and many other bands will take place to on November 20th and 21st at Lakefront Arena in New Orleans to coincide with the release of *Volume V*. One- and two-day tickets are available here: 

[The Great NOLA Trendkill Tickets](https://www.ticketmaster.com/the-great-nola-trendkill-2-day-ticket-new-orleans-11-20-2026/event/1B006522ED382003?ref=thisdayinmetal.com)

![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/db/e2/dbe2ac7e-62ef-4b13-917a-63221a045127/content/images/2026/11/attachment-the_great_nola_trendkill.webp)